IN THE NEWS
Defense Verdict – Erb’s Palsy – Negligent Obstetric Case
On October 6, 2026, after a hard-fought four-week trial in Richmond County, partners John Paterniti and Fabiana Furgal secured a defense verdict for an obstetrician client accused of negligence during the delivery of the infant plaintiff. It was undisputed that the...
Summary Judgment Granted in Supreme Court, Queens County
Senior Partner, John Paterniti and Associate, Josie Accetturi, successfully moved for summary judgment on behalf of our client, an OBGYN. This matter involved an alleged failure to timely diagnose and treat an ectopic pregnancy. Plaintiff contended that the delay...
Senior Partner, John Paterniti, selected for the 2026 Edition of Best Lawyers

John D. Paterniti
PARTNER
John D. Paterniti
PARTNER
John D. Paterniti co-heads the firm’s Medical Malpractice defense team and is a senior partner in the General Liability practice group. As a seasoned trial attorney, he has tried more than 50 cases to verdict over the course of his career in the New York City area and surrounding counties. John leads a team of partners and associates in defending major hospital systems, individual physicians, and long-term care facilities in a wide variety of medical malpractice claims. He regularly tries high exposure cases, that require the skill to navigate the complexities of the medical issues as well as the significant damages involved. John has successfully defended clients at trial in cases ranging from claims of obstetrical mismanagement leading to permanent global disabilities to neurosurgical negligence resulting in paralysis. He also represents clients at mediation and at administrative hearings before the NYS Office of Professional Medical Conduct.
A graduate of Fordham University School of Law, John served as an Assistant Corporation Counsel for the City of New York in Bronx County from 1996 to 2004. As a Senior Counsel in the office, he defended the City in numerous high-profile matters involving false arrest and excessive force claims against the NYPD, claims of civil rights violations, premises liability, actions against the Department of Education, as well as Labor Law violation claims. In 2004, John joined a highly regarded defense firm in New York City where he specialized in medical malpractice defense.
In his General Liability practice, John represents clients in claims including premises liability, work-site accidents, negligent security and property damage.
Defense Verdict – Erb’s Palsy – Negligent Obstetric Case
On October 6, 2026, after a hard-fought four-week trial in Richmond County, partners John Paterniti and Fabiana Furgal secured a defense verdict for an obstetrician client accused of negligence during the delivery of the infant plaintiff. It was undisputed that the...
Summary Judgment Granted in Supreme Court, Queens County
Senior Partner, John Paterniti and Associate, Josie Accetturi, successfully moved for summary judgment on behalf of our client, an OBGYN. This matter involved an alleged failure to timely diagnose and treat an ectopic pregnancy. Plaintiff contended that the delay...